Scrutiny councillors voted to take the Western Road Red Route call-in no further, so the scheme went ahead. The minutes show what officers promised traders.
The call-in of the Western Road Red Route failed. Fourteen opposition councillors had called in the Cabinet decision of 17 September that approved the scheme. On Tuesday 6 October the council’s Place Overview and Scrutiny Committee voted by a majority to take the challenge no further, so the decision could be carried out.
Updated 16 November: the committee’s minutes are now published (minutes, 6 October 2026). They record that the majority voted that “the challenge to the decision called-in should be taken no further and the decision may be implemented”. The chair, Councillor Evans, said she would like the scheme to come back to scrutiny at a later date. What officers and the cabinet member told the committee:
- There were 2,315 recorded “driveaways” on Western Road in 2025/26, drivers who left before a ticket could be issued. Officers said none were Blue Badge holders and very few were deliveries.
- The council has about 40 enforcement officers on duty at any one time for the whole city, and Western Road is its most heavily patrolled stretch.
- Average eastbound bus journey times from Hove Town Hall to Churchill Square have risen by 16.7%, Councillor Taylor said.
- On the existing red routes, the bus company reports reliability up from 75% to 77% on London Road and from 80% to 84% on Lewes Road. The same measures will be used on Western Road.
- Mobile phone data showed footfall on London Road up 2% after its red route. London Road has 192 businesses and 7 vacant sites.
- Every Western Road business will get a letter with a named contact, and officers said a bay can be moved within a few days under the experimental order. The council is also looking at bookable loading bays.
- Councillor Taylor put the expected revenue at about £50,000 and said the decision “is not about revenue”. He said there is no assumption the red route will become permanent; a future Cabinet decides that.
The order came into force on 9 November on the council’s list of traffic orders. The council had not announced the start of camera enforcement when we checked on 16 November.
Updated 26 October: the call-in did not stop the scheme. The council made the experimental Red Route order, TRO-21-2026, on 15 October, and it comes into force on Monday 9 November. Objections to keeping it permanently can be sent until 9 May 2027 (council notice). The committee’s minutes of 6 October have still not been published.
The committee could not cancel the Red Route itself. It could let the decision stand, or send it back to Cabinet with its concerns. The papers were published under urgency rules because the call-in has to be decided within seven working days (call-in report).
What Cabinet decided
On 17 September Cabinet agreed that an Experimental Traffic Regulation Order for Western Road, between Holland Road and Montpelier Road, “should proceed”. It set the scheme’s primary aim as reducing congestion “to allow for improved bus reliability during the experimental period” (draft Cabinet minutes). We reported the decision and the council’s figures in our earlier story.
The draft minutes add some detail the decision list did not:
- Councillor Trevor Muten, the cabinet member for transport, left the chamber for the item after declaring an interest
- officers cited more than 1,100 enforcement visits in the previous year and more than 2,300 occasions when vehicles left before a penalty could be issued
- officers corrected an error in the consultation appendix over the number of people recorded as “not sure” on one question
- existing disabled bays in side roads plus the new ones would give about 20 disabled spaces in the area
Who called it in, and why
The call-in was signed by seven Green councillors, five Conservatives, one Brighton & Hove Independent Party councillor and one independent (call-in report). The council’s rules need at least six members from more than one group. The Chief Executive and the Monitoring Officer have confirmed this request complies.
The signatories rely on one ground: “the absence of sufficient evidence on which to base a decision”. Their reasons, in full, are that (call-in request):
- no Western Road-specific evidence supports the scheme’s stated primary objective
- the report’s summary of the consultation was partial, and no written comments, including those from businesses, were provided
- the loading provision is not tested against the council’s own evidence of demand
- the economic effect of the scheme is to be assessed only after it is in place
What the Cabinet report itself says
Some of those points are acknowledged in the Cabinet report. It says “the specific effects on Western Road cannot be determined in advance”. It accepts the street has “limited rear servicing opportunities”, unlike some other Red Routes. The furthest any business would be from a loading bay is about 70 metres.
The report’s answer is the experiment itself. An experimental order lets the council gather Western Road evidence, monitor footfall and loading bay use, and change the layout quickly. Officers argue the uncertainties “support the use of an Experimental Traffic Regulation Order rather than weigh against it”.
The report weighed two alternatives. One was not proceeding at all. The other was a permanent order from the start. It did not set out a lighter option such as stepped-up enforcement under the current yellow lines.
The traders’ case
The committee heard two public deputations, one on behalf of Western Road traders and one in support of the scheme (traders’ deputation). The traders’ deputation says the scheme affects 185 businesses, and makes these points:
- the report “never weighed anything less” than double red lines and camera enforcement
- ten loading bays serve nearly a kilometre of shopfront with no rear access
- the Brewery Logistics Group, whose members deliver to pubs on the street, has warned that kegs weigh up to 200kg
- traders on the Lewes Road and London Road Red Routes describe lost takings and closures, and one charity shop says its profits fell from £75,000 to £35,000 a year
Those are the traders’ own accounts and figures, as submitted to the committee, and we have not been able to check them. The Cabinet report says evidence from the other corridors shows “slightly increased footfall” after Red Routes went in. It adds that “the precise contribution made by the schemes cannot be isolated”.
The deputation also points out that Western Road is shut for resurfacing, so no Red Route can operate yet. It asks for a pause to run the economic impact assessment that it says the Chamber of Commerce and the business improvement districts have requested. Traders offer to share their trading figures during the closure.
The committee’s options
The committee had three options under the call-in report:
| Outcome | What it means |
|---|---|
| Take it no further | The Cabinet decision is implemented |
| Refer to full Council | Only if it finds the decision breaches the policy or budget framework |
| Refer back to Cabinet | Cabinet must reconsider, with the committee’s concerns set out |
A decision can only be sent back for reconsideration once. Even if Cabinet looks again, it keeps the final say.
What it means for you
- If you run a business on Western Road, the red route is an experimental order, so you can object or ask for a bay to be moved. Objections can be sent until 9 May 2027 through the council’s traffic orders page. Officers told the committee every business will get a letter with a named contact.
- If you drive or deliver, there is no stopping or waiting at any time between Holland Road and Montpelier Road once the red route is enforced. Use the marked loading and disabled bays.
- If you use the buses, Western Road reopened on 10 and 11 November with routes back on their normal line. Bus reliability is the measure the council says it will use to judge the scheme.
Have your say